In this study, we showed that 2D and 3D/4D transperineal ultrasound can be used to examine the PFM during singing. We found that female classically trained singers had good voluntary contraction of the PFM and that they contracted their pelvic floor during singing.

There are few studies with an interdisciplinary view integrating physical medicine with focus on the pelvic floor and singing voice research [2]. Rudavsky et al. used bladder shape distortion visualised with transabdominal ultrasound as a proxy for pelvic floor contraction in ten men and women and found changes in bladder shape during singing, interpreted as a sign of pelvic floor activity [9]. Bedekar et al. conducted a pilot study and showed that singing can be used to train the PFM [15]. They found that activation of the PFMs during singing improved PFM strength assessed by palpation and sEMG after 3–4 weeks of singing practice. Talasz et al. found a positive correlation between PFM function assessed by palpation and expiratory flow in nulliparous women [16]. In another study they found a parallel movement of the thoracic diaphragm and PFM during breathing and coughing, using dynamic MRI, supporting that the PFM plays a role in breathing [17]. In that study they only assessed the craniocaudal displacement of the pelvic floor, and their results could imply that the PFM was passively yielding to the movement of the thoracic diaphragm and increased intraabdominal pressure. Different techniques for assessment of pelvic floor contraction makes direct comparison to other studies challenging, but most studies support an active role of the PFM during breathing, expiration and singing.

We used three different measurements to assess PFM contraction, where levator hiatal anteroposterior diameter measured in the 2D image is the easiest to perform. This technique requires no post-processing of ultrasound volumes, and it has been correlated to palpation and perineometry in previous studies and has shown high interrater interclass correlation (ICC) [11, 18]. Similarly, levator hiatal areas decreased significantly during active contraction. A significant change in 2D levator hiatal AP diameter from standing rest to singing suggests a moderate to strong involvement of the PFM in the singing process. Levator hiatal area also decreased slightly from the supine position to standing, with further decrease during singing, but these changes did not reach statistical significance. We also included a measurement of the bladder neck’s cranio-caudal distance from the symphysis and found that the bladder neck was significantly elevated during voluntary contraction in the supine position. Vertical movement of the bladder neck has been suggested as an indirect measurement of pelvic floor contraction in other studies [13, 19]. In the present study, the bladder neck descended when standing, with a further descent during singing. These latter changes did not reach statistical significance, but we interpret this “paradoxical” descent as an effect of the power of gravity on the urinary bladder and intraabdominal organs when standing up rather than relaxation of the pelvic floor. The bladder neck descended further during singing, probably because of increased intraabdominal pressure created during singing. The PFM contraction observed on singing may be a reflexive response to increased pressure in the abdominal cavity during diaphragm lowering, or muscle contraction might reflect a certain studied voice technique. We speculate that PFM contraction may have prevented a more significant bladder descent during singing.

Another interesting finding was the moderate positive correlation between BMI and PFM contraction. Previous studies have shown that women with higher BMI have higher intraabdominal pressure and increased risk of pelvic floor disorders, especially urinary incontinence [20]. Women with higher BMI might compensate increased intaraabdominal pressure by increasing their maximum PFM contraction. Thre is, however, a lack of studies regarding the possible correlation between BMI and PFM contraction, and further studies are needed.

The main limitation of this study is the small sample size. Multiple regression analysis including confounders such as age, BMI, pelvic floor muscle injury, parity and mode of delivery (caesarean or normal vaginal delivery) was therefore not possible. Previous studies have shown that vaginally parous women with levator avulsions have weaker PFM contraction [21]. This was also observed in the present study, but did not reach statistical significance due to the small sample size. Furthermore, we had no information on PFM training or symptoms of pelvic floor disorders, and we did not ask if the participants contracted voluntarily during singing. We did not inquire about awareness of changes in sensations in the lower waist and pelvic floor region or whether participants had adopted specific techniques or strategies to enhance their singing control in relation to these sensations. The small sample size also limited the possibility to study any correlation between voluntary contraction in the supine position and contraction during singing. We could not correlate grade of contraction with voice intensity or expiratory flow in our study. Only one person examined the ultrasound volumes, and it could be a weakness that the analyses not were repeated by more persons. On the other hand, she had previously been validated against other ultrasound experts and she had over 10 years of experience in pelvic floor imaging.

To our knowledge, this is the first study using direct ultrasound imaging of the PFM on opera singers both in the supine position and during singing in a natural, standing position. Other strengths are that the singers were examined in both the supine and standing position and we used validated measurements for assessment of PFM contraction. Ultrasound minimises the bias of other techniques, such as the examiners subjective interpretation by palpation of the PFM and coactivation of other muscles by perineometry and sEMG. The inclusion of both parous and nulliparous women increases the external validity of the results.

We have confirmed that ultrasound is a feasible tool in studies of the PFM during singing. The examiner experienced that transperineal ultrasound was more difficult to perform in the standing position during singing, as the women moved slightly during singing and the examiner had to follow the singer’s movement. Nonetheless, most of the ultrasound volumes were of good quality, and we advocate the use of transperineal ultrasound in future studies of PFM action during singing.

This study forms the basis for larger scale studies among singers, and it has implications also for other professions in whom breath control and pelvic floor support is thought to be important, such as wood wind and brass musicians. Pelvic floor ultrasound could be used to test if musically untrained persons contract the pelvic floor similarly during singing and if contraction is correlated with voice quality. One previous study found different contraction patterns in abdominal muscles in untrained versus trained singers [4], and another study found different function of the abdominal muscles in singers with and without functional voice disorders [6]. Future studies should include questions about pelvic floor disorders and symptom scores in classically trained singers. Previous studies have shown that female athletes report high prevalence of pelvic floor disorders and that they use different strategies to control the symptoms [22,23,24]. We could imagine that opera singers are similar to athletes since controlled straining is part of the singing technique, but on the other hand, opera singers could have less PFD because of focus on the PFM during education and good PFM contraction.

Source link